Virtual Workshop Resources

An overview of software, best practices, and logistics for successful virtual events at ICERM.

Virtual Collaboration Tools

ICERM's IT staff supports a wide variety of virtual collaboration tools, software, and platforms. We encourage organizers to contact IT staff before your workshop in order to assure we are ready to support your virtual events.

Zoom Video Conferencing

ICERM uses Zoom as our primary video conferencing service. Workshop events normally use Zoom Meetings, but we occasionally use Zoom's add-on Zoom Webinars feature for more formal virtual events like public lectures. A short comparison of Meetings and Webinars is below. See the Zoom Introduction for more details and a full technical comparison.

Zoom Virtual Meetings

Zoom Meetings provides meetings with video, audio and screen sharing for up to 300 real time participants.

  • ICERM uses Zoom Meetings for most workshop talks, discussion sessions, working group meetings, and virtual social events such as coffee break sessions and workshop receptions.
  • Zoom Meetings allow all participants to control their own microphones, cameras, and screen sharing so they can see, chat, and collaborate with each other.
  • For officially scheduled workshop events, ICERM's IT staff creates the Zoom sessions and shares the links with all participants. A member of ICERM's IT staff also monitors the Zoom session to provide any technical support should the need arise.
  • During long-term programs, ICERM can support a limited number of recurring working group meetings on Zoom.
  • All attendees, speakers, and session chairs are encouraged to review our Zoom Meetings Guide.

Zoom Webinar

Zoom Webinar is an add-on to the Zoom Meetings service that allows more formal webinar broadcasting and live-streaming outside of Zoom.

  • ICERM sometimes uses Webinar for more formal events such as virtual public lectures.
  • Webinar attendees will be in view-only mode but can still raise their hand to request microphone access or use chat to ask questions.
  • Most ICERM Webinars are live-streamed on the icerm.brown.edu website via Panopto.

Zoom Technical Needs/Constraints

Other Video Conferencing Platforms

Gather

Gather is a web-based virtual space that combines a 2D virtual space with video chat, allowing users to move around the virtual space and interact with others in small groups.

  • Users in Gather are represented as a 2D game-style avatar within a virtual world. The standard Gather world has a virtual conference center along with an outdoor area.
  • Users can move their avatars around the space and congregate in groups to have group discussions, allowing more free-form small group discussions than Zoom Breakout rooms.
  • ICERM has been using Gather for recent coffee breaks and other social events.

Technical Needs/Constraints

Email/Text Chat Platforms

Slack

Slack is an app and web based communication platform designed loosely around the classic Internet Relay Chat (IRC) model.

  • Slack divides chat up into “channels” for topic-based discussion.
  • Slack's app is available for all major platforms. A browser-based client is also available.
  • Free Slack workspaces retain the last 10,000 messages for a searchable history and also provide 1-to-1 video calling.
  • Paid Slack workspaces can support group video calling up to 15 people.

Technical Needs/Constraints

Zulip

Zulip is an open-source web-based communication platform similar to Slack.

  • Zulip divides chat up into “streams” (similar to Slack's channels). Streams also have topics to further organize the discussion.
  • Zulip also has apps for all major platforms in addition to a browser-based web client.
  • For ICERM users, Zulip has several benefits over a free Slack workspace:
  1. Zulip has better Latex integration than Slack.
  2. Zulip topics provide an additional level of organization within streams, which can be beneficial during virtual workshops.
  3. Zulip retains the full discussion history. It is hidden for free tiers, but can be viewed by upgrading to the paid tier.

Technical Needs/Constraints

Listserv

Long-term programs (Semester Programs and Summer@ICERM) are provided with a program mailing list via Brown's central listserv. All participants are members of the list and can use it to send email announcements to the other members of their program. Listserv is not available for short-term programs.

Web-based Collaboration

Overleaf

Overleaf is an online collaborative LaTeX editor.

  • Overleaf provides an online collaborative Google Docs-style editor for creating LaTeX documents. Several collaborators can work together on the same document making edits and suggestions/comments.
  • Overleaf is available to all postdocs and Brown university students via Shibboleth login.
  • ICERM can also support premium Overleaf projects for other workshop groups on a case-by-case basis. Organizers should contact IT staff to discuss this option.

Technical Needs/Constraints

JupyterHub

JupyterHub is a collaborative, online, multi-user version of the popular Jupyter Notebook software.

  • Brown CCV hosts a JupyterHub server that can be made available on request to specific working groups.

Technical Needs/Constraints

ICERM's Best Practices for Virtual Events

What follows is a list of best practices for hosting virtual events based on lessons ICERM has learned from our experiences. These points may seem obvious to some, and indeed, they follow ICERM’s general operating philosophy. However, we list them here in the interest of furthering the broader discussion of facilitating continued research in a virtual environment.

Keep It Simple

This is perhaps the most important principle, and it overlaps a lot of areas. Remember that not everyone has the same level of technical knowledge and confidence. When choosing a conferencing application, make sure the interfaces, at least for the basic options, are intuitive and user friendly. Application client downloads should be easy to access. Installs and configurations should require minimal effort on the part of the user.

We also strongly recommend, where possible, choosing tools that are platform agnostic, widely accessible, and require minimal hardware. Any one of these could hinder a user’s ability to participate.

The logistics of participation should be simple as well. For example When hosting multiple sessions within a single event, a shared link for all sessions is recommended if possible to reduce confusion.

Where security is concerned, consider carefully how much you really need, and don’t secure beyond that. Registrations and passwords add complexity to the user experience and may make more hassle than some are willing to endure to participate. We realize this won’t be a popular idea among security minded IT people. The balance between security and usability needs to be adjusted carefully, especially when the goal is broad accessibility for a large set of users with unknown or poorly defined operating parameters.

Practice

Ideally, the support staff should be experts with the tools being used. Anyone with an active role, such as session chairs, panelists, speakers, should be given an opportunity to familiarize themselves with additional functions they may need to use before the actual event. For example, our team provides speakers with an opportunity to schedule practice time in order to try out screen sharing functions and the like the week before an event. Unusual transitions or special functionality should be mapped out and tested ahead of time.

Organization

Session chairs have proven to be a vital part of the logistics of our virtual events, particularly when running events that have multiple talks in a session. Chair duties are similar to in-person workshops, including speaker introductions, moderating the audience for questions, and keeping the session generally on schedule. Ideal chairs will have some knowledge of the scientific topics being discussed.

Support

ICERM has a team member actively monitoring, but not participating in all virtual events. This person is primarily there to help if there are technical issues, but also serves as another check on chat logs to make sure there isn’t an overly large backlog of unanswered questions, and to assist with things like speaker transitions and breakout rooms. Generally this person serves as “meeting host” from a technical standpoint, and has full control of the application used for the event.

Communicate

This is perhaps as important as simplicity. Communicating early and often allows clear expectations to be set for everyone involved. Open dialogs as early as possible with anyone in an active role. Make sure they understand what it is they’re expected to do and when. Ensure that everyone understands what your tools will and won’t do. Provide links to documentation and how-to guides as well as any necessary software downloads.

Be Flexible

Virtual events introduce a wide variety of factors that are outside the control of the host. Internet connections drop or are bogged down. Pets and people make surprise appearances. Hardware breaks or is suddenly inaccessible. Have a contingency plan, such as a stand in speaker, or a backup QA session. We also recommend having multiple means of contact for speakers and panelists (i.e. email and phone) in case they are unexpectedly absent.

Virtual Workshop Session Formats

Standard Lecture Talk

A standard lecture talk by a presenter delivered via Zoom. Usually scheduled for 45 minutes plus 15 minutes Q&A.

Technical Needs/Constraints

Lightning Talks

A series of short 5 to 10 minute “lightning” talks hosted back-to-back, usually presented by early-career researchers and graduate students. Each presenter is typically limited to two slides.

Technical Needs/Constraints

Panel Discussion

A discussion and question/answer session led by several panelists. Panel discussions sometimes have one or two moderators as well.

Technical Needs/Constraints

A virtual poster gallery on the event web page.

Technical Needs/Constraints

“Make Your Own Coffee” Hour

An informal social discussion session for workshop attendees to meet and mingle with each other virtually.

Technical Needs/Constraints

Problem Sessions and Discussion Sessions

Session for attendees to gather either in the full group or smaller breakout groups and discuss topics or problems related to the research area of the workshop.

Technical Needs/Constraints

Project/Group Work Sessions

Small working group sessions during project-based or group-based workshops. These sessions are usually ongoing throughout the week of the workshop.

Technical Needs/Constraints

Zoom Video Conferencing

Zoom is the official video conferencing service of ICERM and Brown University. ICERM uses both Zoom Meetings and Zoom Webinar for our events.

Zoom Video Conferencing

Overview of Zoom at ICERM

Zoom is the official video conferencing service of ICERM and Brown University. ICERM uses both Zoom Meetings and Zoom Webinar for our events.

Downloading Zoom

General Zoom Info & Tips

  • Zoom has apps for macOS, Windows, and Linux available for download on the Zoom.us website (https://zoom.us/download/). iOS and Android apps are also available on the App Store/Google Play Store. Zoom will work best if you keep it up to date to the latest version, available through the download link.
  • Please join the Zoom sessions with your full name.
  • We recommend using headphones to reduce the chance of echo, feedback, or other audio issues.
  • Zoom can be bandwidth and resource-intensive for your computer. For best performance, we recommend a wired connection, if possible, and running as few other concurrent applications as possible while participating.
  • We encourage users to add a profile photo to their Zoom account so that it will show up when you are speaking without a camera on.
  • Zoom has a great user guide and knowledge base available at https://support.zoom.us/.

FAQs & Zoom Support Pages

Zoom's full user guide and knowledgebase available at https://support.zoom.us/. Some commonly used Zoom features at ICERM along with direct links to their support pages on Zoom's website are below.

Meetings vs. Webinars

Zoom Virtual Meetings

Zoom Meetings provides meetings with video, audio and screen sharing for up to 300 real time participants.

  • ICERM uses Zoom Meetings for most workshop talks, discussion sessions, working group meetings, and virtual social events such as coffee break sessions and workshop receptions.
  • Zoom Meetings allow all participants to control their own microphones, cameras, and screen sharing so they can see, chat, and collaborate with each other.
  • For officially scheduled workshop events, ICERM's IT staff creates the Zoom sessions and shares the links with all participants. A member of ICERM's IT staff also monitors the Zoom session to provide any technical support should the need arise.
  • During long-term programs, ICERM can support a limited number of recurring working group meetings on Zoom.
  • All attendees, speakers, and session chairs are encouraged to review our Zoom Meetings Guide.

Zoom Webinar

Zoom Webinar is an add-on to the Zoom Meetings service that allows more formal webinar broadcasting and live-streaming outside of Zoom.

  • ICERM sometimes uses Webinar for more formal events such as virtual public lectures.
  • Webinar attendees will be in view-only mode but can still raise their hand to request microphone access or use chat to ask questions.
  • Most ICERM Webinars are live-streamed on the icerm.brown.edu website via Panopto.

Technical Comparison for Organizers

Meetings

Webinars

Zoom Video Conferencing

Zoom Meetings Guide

This guide contains ICERM's general guidelines and tips for workshop talks, classes, working groups, and meetings via Zoom Meetings. We recommend all Zoom participants read and follow these guidelines to ensure the best experience for all participants.

General Zoom Info & Tips

  • Zoom has apps for macOS, Windows, and Linux available for download on the Zoom.us website (https://zoom.us/download/). iOS and Android apps are also available on the App Store/Google Play Store. Zoom will work best if you keep it up to date to the latest version, available through the download link.
  • Please join the Zoom sessions with your full name.
  • We recommend using headphones to reduce the chance of echo, feedback, or other audio issues.
  • Zoom can be bandwidth and resource-intensive for your computer. For best performance, we recommend a wired connection, if possible, and running as few other concurrent applications as possible while participating.
  • We encourage users to add a profile photo to their Zoom account so that it will show up when you are speaking without a camera on.
  • Zoom has a great user guide and knowledge base available at https://support.zoom.us/.

Zoom Workshops at ICERM

Info for Speakers

Info for Organizers and Session Chairs

Screen Sharing

Lightning Talks

Zoom Video Conferencing

Zoom Webinars Guide

This guide contains ICERM's general guidelines and tips for formal ICERM virtual talks delivered via Zoom Webinar. We ask that all participants, speakers, and session chairs read and follow these guidelines to ensure the best experience for all participants.

Zoom has apps for macOS, Windows, and Linux available for download on the Zoom.us website (https://zoom.us/download/). iOS and Android apps are also available on the App Store/Google Play Store. Once you have the app installed on your device, you can join the virtual talk session by clicking the Zoom link in the email you received from ICERM staff.

For All Participants

For Speakers

For Session Chairs